Character Guide ⇩
►Neil Joston → 18, main character, male, dad in jail, mother dead, not his real name, dark hair dye, brown contacts, father is a murderer, 18 but paperwork says age 19, speaks German, (real name: Nathaniel Abram Wesninski), #10 Fox
►Andrew Minyard → 20, blonde, 5 feet tall, goalkeeper, spent 3 years in Juvie, twin, speaks german, weekly therapy sessions, takes medication that makes him manic, (required to take it for 3 years while on parole), gay, sort of has a “free pass” to do whatever he wants because of his mental health and traumatic past
►Wymack → Coach
►Aaron Minyard→ 20, “the normal twin”, speaks german, likes Caitlin
►Kevin Day → Face tattoo, Striker position
►Nicholas “Nicky” Hemmick → has a long distance boyfriend, Minyard cousin, speaks german, sophmore, 100% the comic relief
►Riko Morriyama → Kevin’s adopted brother
►Abigail “Abby” Winfield → Nurse
►Betsy “Bee” → Team therapist
►Nathan Wesninski → Neil’s father, “The Butcher of Baltimore”
►Matthew “Matt” Boyd → with Dan, has a brotherly relationship with Neil
►Dan → Team captain, ex-stripper, with Matt
►Seth Gordon → 5th year senior
►Edgar Allan Ravens → Riko’s Exy’s team
►Luthor → Nicky’s dad, homophobic, religious
►Maria → Nicky’s mum, homophobic, religious
►Lola Malcolm → got rid of the bodies of the people Neil’s father killed
- Is this a good series? No
- Should this have been more heavily edited? Yes
- Who is this series aimed at? 100% torture porn-loving 2010 tumblr girls
- Did I enjoy it? I’m honestly not sure
- Is the fanart fanastic? Absolutely yes, do yourself a favour and check it out
A quick summary:
- Sport, Angst, Violence, Sport, So many trigger warnings, Very 2010 tumblr fanfiction (if you know, you know)
- I heard this described somewhere as “Gay Sports Mafia” (Update: Kat talks about it around the 3 minute mark of her review, which you can watch here.) and I’d say that’s a pretty accurate desciption except that the only really consistent part of the series is the sports aspect. The series uses a really violent take on Lacrosse, called “Exy” which is used as a constistent plot device and motivator for the main character thoughout the trilogy. The mafia and gay aspects only really comes into play towards the end of the trilogy (from what I can remember, they become important in book 3. Mafia stuff might have happened at the end of book 2, I can’t really remember at this point).
If you’re looking for trigger warnings or a quick overview of my thoughts on the trilogy, without spoilers just skip to the end of the review!
The Foxhole Court
TW: physical abuse, parental abuse, alcoholism, talk of violence, talk of rape (in jesting), use of word f*ggot, use of r word (more than once), drugs, drug overdose, murder
My initial reaction after finishing the book: “This was genuinely awful but I kind of want to read book 2.”
Okay, so where to start? I’ll bullet point some of my smaller thoughts and then get into my bigger points after, if that works for eveyrone? It does? Great, you’re a peach.
- Mediocre writing that could’ve used some editing. The pacing was a bit off and there was definitely a lot of info dumping so there was never really any time to get to know the characters.
- VERY confusing! Everything just started happening from the word go and never really slowed down.
- I didn’t really don’t get the hype so far, I’m assuming it’s the easy writing and Tumblr obssessiveness that people like about the books?? I’d be interested to know if people felt the same way about the author’s other works.
- Captive Prince meets The Raven Cycle but badly written. Basically, it’s every 2012 Tumblr user’s wet dream. Angst and inevitably gay.
- Very long chapters
- I have literally no idea how ‘Exy’ (the sport the novel centers around) works. I’ve heard it’s basically a violent version of Lacrosse but I’m honestly not convinced Lacrosse is even a real game tbh.
- Every single one of these characters is so dysfunctional it hurts.
The book is quite ridiculous honestly so you’ve got to suspend your disbelief a fair bit. Also when I say this is a violent series, I’m not joking at all so maybe read an excerpt or two before commiting because otherwise it won’t be worth your time and it’ll be more torture than porn. I think this is a great trilogy if you’re in a bit of a weird mood and you want to get unhealthily attached to a group of characters in a short amount of time but otherwise maybe you’ll want to give it a miss, I really think it depends on who you are as a reader and also the mood you’re in when you pick up the books.
In general, this series has a pretty large focus on the boys, if you’re not a part of Andrew’s one of the boys on the Exy team) “family” then you’re not really talked about or focused on very much. So, by default the three girls in the series (I had to look up their names but here they are: Dan, Alison & Renee) sort of became the same person in my head as a I was reading and I often had to google which one was which while I was reading. So I think they all come across as pretty 2D. I think if this was written and published through a traditional publishing house now, this would be different or, even if this was a tv show they would have more development and focus, but that’s not the case here obviously. For context, this book was self-published by the author and was released on Amazon in 2013.
You know the whole thing about not being able to look away from a car crash? That’s this book. It’s a mess. It’s chaotic and violent and soo badly written but there’s something compelling about it. I don’t know if what drew me in was the hype or the characters or purely that the book was short. But, I managed to finish it in a matter of hours. That being said, this was something like my fourth attempt at reading the book so getting past chapter 2 was a big accomplishment for me.
The Raven King
TW: physical abuse, familial/parental abuse, conversion camp, rape (on-page) & discussion, use of r word (once), physical beating, talk of violence, drugs, talk of drug overdose, murder, physical violence (torture)
My initial reaction after finishing the book: “Well, book 3 is certainly going to be interesting. This series is like some seriously fucked kind of torture porn.”
- I’m not a sports person unless the sport is swimming or tennis, so i have no clue how Exy works. I wish there was a mini guide or a page explaining the rules at the back or front of the book!
- This was very much just an exploration of Neil and getting to know the other characters + a much larger focus on Exy so yeah, not much to take notes on.
The King’s Men
TW:PTSD, physical violence and abuse, on-page torture (graphic), talk of rape, talk of drug use, murder (on-page), kidnapping, panic attacks
My initial reaction after finishing the book: “What a wild fucking ride. At this point, I barely know what to say. I didn’t love this series by any means, and I can’t ever see myself re-reading it. But, I do think that each book improved as I kept reading the trilogy and I did like Neil as a main character. Overall, the writing was pretty average and this is basically dumpster fire 2012 Tumblr torture porn but I’m a sucker for the found family trope, so overall I am glad, at least, that I can say that I’ve read this trilogy.”
- Oh boy, there’s a lot of tension in this one, folks!
- This book is significantly longer than the first two! It’s like almost an extra 100 pages and you can tell, it definitely feels like those extra pages have been tacked on! I felt like the main plot finished, we took a 50 page break and then the author was ready to finish up any other extra plot lines.
- It’s weird, but I both appreciate that space to use as a breather and loathe it because actually being forced by the author to take that break was kind of annoying. In the end, the book felt like it was getting too long and I defintiely wanted it to be over.
- I found that I didn’t care at all about the plot, but I did grow attached to the characters (most of the time) so I liked that extra time because it afforded more page time for characters to learn and develop but I also didn’t like it at the same time because it just meant there was more plot stuff to tallk about and prepare for which I didn’t care about so much.
- I’m torn between rereading this series immediately and never going near it again
It’s interesting, I read this trilogy way back in April so I’ve clearly had some time away from it to think and I really think that when you take a break from the series, it’s really easy to see it’s flaws. This series is cracked af and being held together by duct tape, hope and some seriously old bandaids. I read book 1 in one day then I read book 2 the next day and immediately started book 3 which i finished the last 10% of the day after. Having that time in between really makes you think about the problems with the series so I think if I ever decided to give this trilog a re-read, I’m defintiely goin gto come out of it with a different perspective on the series.
Okay so I am a gold-class sucker for some good character development. I think Kevin probably had the best development throughout the series and I also think he was probably the character who had the most realistic reaction to the trauma he suffered so I do enjoy some of the scenes he has towards the end of this book.
In terms of Neil, I also think he has some great character development. The way he went from timid and basically hiding, to how he acts in this book is fantastic. Also, the evolution of the found family trope gives me emotions okay.
But oh boy! Andrew. This boy had zero character development which I think is kind of sad because he had probably some of the most, if not the most potential for amazing character development out of everyone in the series. But, he ended up never really changing or evolving throughout any of the books. He also is probably the unhealthiest character in the way he thinks and rationalises his thoughts and 100% in the way he treats, or rather, mistreats his “family”.
*NON SPOILER* TRILOGY THOUGHTS
Okay, so… The Foxhole Court trilogy. What did I think?
I think this is any 2010 Tumblr-girl’s wet dream. There’s angst, there’s gay boys, there’s drama and there’s a butt-ton of mental health and family issues. So, do with that information, what you will.
In all seriousness, I do want to stress that this trilogy does deal with a lot of serious and sensitive subjects, in not so sensitive ways so if you have any triggers I highly recommend searching out trigger warnings before giving the books a go!
Also, I was asked at one point, who I would recommend these books to and it stumped me for a while but, I think I’ve figured it out. If you get attached to characters quickly (usually sad bois) and love the found family trope because you have a tendancy to fall in love with big groups of characters then I think this is the book series for you. I found that the trilogy gave me big Captive Prince vibes because of how addictive it is and the group dynamics really reminded me of The Raven Cycle. So, hopefully that helps.
I also think that this is a great series for anyone who needs something short and addictive for a readathon! I listened to the series on audiobook in less than 48 hours so, I can definitely say, it’s perfect for when you’re in a fast-paced reading mood! The Foxhole Court trilogy is like a bag of chips, it’s not good for you but once you’ve started it’s hard to stop.
TW: Violence (weapons, physical fights etc.), Sexual assault & Rape (on page, graphic), Drug abuse, Drug overdose, Drug misrepresentation (Antipsychotics), Alcohol abuse, Murder (mentions, on page), Torture (on page, graphic), Abuse (familial, mental, physical), Homophobia, Self-harm, Panic attacks, Mentions of suicide, Character in a re-hab or mental facility & abuse within that facility, Ablesist language, Homophobic slurs, Mentions of animal cruelty, Use of ‘R’ word (multiple times), Mentions of conversion camps, Kidnapping
↣ trigger warnings gathered from multiple reviews + my own reading of the series.
Have you read the ‘All For The Game’ trilogy?
Do you have a favourite book or charcater in the trilogy?
Goodreads | StoryGraph | Instagram | Letterboxd | TV Time | Twitter | Tumblr
5 thoughts on “The Foxhole Court Trilogy *Spoiler Free* Review // Captive Prince x The Raven Cycle but badly written”
Hahha, thanks for warning me in the title as someone who has certainly obsessed too much about these books. I totally agree that so many elements (like the sport exy as a whole) does not make sense, and I think that’s why it’s never been picked up by official publisher – too many things would have to change. So definitely see why you don’t like it.
I think many that loves this book series is in it for the found family trope, that it’s queer and I’ve certainly struggled to find the same type of character as Neil in other books.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree, I think the series would change too much if it was picked up by a publisher, but I think it would be interesting to see it adapted to screen. I wonder how much they would keep and how much would change?
I agree I think the found family aspect is a big part of why so many people love this series! I’ve had the same problem, Neil seems to be a rare character type!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha I love reading your review, Ellyn! I honestly have no interest of reading this book, but the fanarts and edits for this series are GORGEOUS, like they literally get the best talent on tumblr they really intrigue me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you Tasya!
Haha, I never had any interest in the series either but I kept seeing people talk about it so I decided to give it a go!
I agree omg the fanart is so so good! 😍😍😍