City of Bones (2007) *Mild Spoilers* Review // GIVING CASSEROLE CLAM A SECOND CHANCE🤯🤯


City of Bones (The Mortal Instruments, #1)

TITLE: City of Bones

AUTHOR: Cassandra Clare

SERIES? Book 1/ 6 “The Mortal Instruments”


TRIGGER WARNINGS: Death, Abusive Parenting, Homophobia

TAGS: Gay side-character

PUBLICATION DATE: May 27th, 2007


When fifteen-year-old Clary Fray heads out to the Pandemonium Club in New York City, she hardly expects to witness a murder― much less a murder committed by three teenagers covered with strange tattoos and brandishing bizarre weapons. Then the body disappears into thin air. It’s hard to call the police when the murderers are invisible to everyone else and when there is nothing―not even a smear of blood―to show that a boy has died. Or was he a boy?…

Character Guide   ⇩

Clary Fray → Main character. Artist, 16, red hair, raised Mundane.
Simon Lewis → Clary’s best friend, Mundane. Funny, in a band with no name.
Jace Wayland → Shadowhunter. Blond hair, cocky/arrogant/straight up mean. Can be funny, depending on your humour. I personally don’t like him if you hadn’t already guessed. Honestly, I imagine he’d fit in really well in a show like The Bold and the Beautiful, he’ so dramatic.
Alec Lightwood → Shadowhunter. Black hair, kinda mean, gay af but in the closet. 18
Izzy (Isabelle) Lightwood → Shadowhunter. Black hair, long legs, beautiful, needs a hug. 16
Luke Garroway → Clary’s father figure.
Magnus Bane → High Warlock of Brooklyn. No belly button.


“It means ‘Shadowhunters: Looking Better in Black Than the Widows of our Enemies Since 1234’.”

Okay, so I’ll address this in a later post at some point probably but I have a pretty rocky past with Cassandra Clare. I’ve read The Mortal Instruments before and wasn’t a big fan but finished the series because peer pressure is real. I didn’t enjoy most of the characters or the plots and it pretty quickly became a big thing to hate on CC so I semi-jumped on that bandwagon. Hence, the name my friends and I adopted for her, “Casserole Clam”.

Anyway, lately, I’ve realised that my views of CC were unfair and that I needed to take a serious look at how I view her and her books, so I decided to give this book a try and see where I go from there. So here we are, at my City of Bones review. I hope you enjoy!

“Where there is love, there is often also hate. They can exist side by side.”


My main good thought about City of Bones is that I didn’t hate it! I went into this with an open mind but I really wasn’t sure how I would feel about the book since it was written so long ago!

Also, another thought I have is that because of the mortal cup, Simon is probably going to become a Shadowhunter because I think at some point he randomly became an archery badass and it was a beautiful moment and one of the only legit surprises in the whole book.  So, is that ever going to become a thing, and if not is he at least going to continue being an archery badass, or no, because you’re only allowed one archery badass in the group???

Annnnd… that’s somehow all the positive notes I had on the entire book. WOW. So here are some quick and fun bullet points because I did actually enjoy my time reading this.

  • I love Isabelle, someone needs to hug her
  • I’m interested in Alec but, if he doesn’t get some super character development I’ll RIOT
  • I think the group dynamic has potential, especially with a Mundane in the mix
  • Honestly, Luke was a whole surprise but he was also super fun. Also, surprise #2 Luke does not look like Isaiah Mustafa???? A travesty, if I ever I saw one.
  • The writing’s not as bad as I thought it was going to be, it’s really not that bad.
  • It started out a bit slow but as soon as it picked up I was right into the story and I flew through it!
  • I appreciate that there’s a gay main character (ish) and that he will hopefully have a plotline???

“Keep in mind that when your mother fled from the Shadow World, it wasn’t the monsters she was hiding from. Not the warlocks, the wolf-men, the Fair Folk, not even the demons themselves. It was them. It was the Shadowhunters.”


It’s pretty easy to take the Micky out of the book, to be honest. Here’s a legit note I took while I was reading and it’s lowkey hilarious because I’m clearly a mess. ↴

“Jace is real fucking dramatic about his past. *Yeah, my dad’s dead he got me an eagle, I’ve seen blood blah blah *looks over into the distance* I’m so badass and mysterious, look at my hair.*”

Basically, the characters are REALLY dramatic and also very very young at times. Also, here’s something that bugged me the entire time I was reading the book. How the hell old are these characters??? In the beginning, I got the impression that Clary & Simon were underage and I feel like someone mentioned they were 16 and Alec was 18 (…I think) but the way they talk, they manage to sound both incredibly young & naive and also like they’re in the mid-twenties. So, yeah, some major character wobbles but, I’m hoping that will be ironed out in later books because characters talking like this ↴ every couple of pages is not only gross but, it’s also… wait, no, it’s just gross.

“Don’t.” Clary raised a warning hand. “I’m not really in the mood right now.”
“That’s got to be the first time a girl’s ever said that to me,” Jace mused.”

Also, isn’t Jace meant to be the best Shadowhunter of all time and isn’t Izzy meant to be a super-sl*t? Or am I misremembering from the show and Clary’s super fun and excessive hatred for girls who don’t look, speak and act like herself?

Jace is described as one of the best Shadowhunters of all time but he’s also super unobservant and gets surprise-attacked & injured a bunch of times throughout this book, which is honestly baffling and also hilarious to me. Because he’s a kid and this whole plot-thread rings false to me.

Also, now let’s talk about the girl hate because I know that this book was written in 2007 and all women in literature hated eachother in the early 2000s but like, Clary doesn’t ever have even one nice thing to say about Isabelle and it’s harsh af. Like, there’s a scene where Izzy loses Simon at a party and starts crying. Like, ya girl is stressed and probably also really tired and you’ve legit left her to babysit your basic b*tch best friend, and now your boyfriend’s sister is crying because you can’t be a beautiful badass all the time ya know??? ya know???

Basically, in order for me to not want to continue banging my head against the nearest concrete wall over this issue I’m going to need CC to work on a wonderful and thriving group dynamic. I need ALec to get along with at least one character and if that character end up being Clary and they end up becoming friends that wouldn’t b the s worst thing in the world. And, if Clary and Isabelle also became friends I’d be down with that too. (or, lbr, she could just dump Jace like the boring bag of sh*t that he is and just date Izzy, if you’re picking up what I’m not so subtly putting down.

“To love is to destroy, and that to be loved is to be the one destroyed.”

Overall, I went into this with low expectations, I really wasn’t expecting to enjoy this, let alone come out of this wanting to read the rest of the books set in this world. I had some issues with this because let’s be real, it’s a debut novel and it’s from a million years ago. But, in all honesty, this book was a fun time and I actually had some really different thoughts on the characters with this re-read and I was really digging the experience.

I’ll definitely be re-reading the rest of the series and maybe continuing on with CC’s other books (don’t get too excited, we’ll see) in the Shadowhunter world. Honestly, I’m pretty excited about this whole thing. Let me know if you want me to review the other books in the series!


Have you read City of Bones? Should I Read more of CC’s books?

I HAVE HAVEgoodreadsiconinstagramiconpinteresticontumblricontwittericon


13 thoughts on “City of Bones (2007) *Mild Spoilers* Review // GIVING CASSEROLE CLAM A SECOND CHANCE🤯🤯

  1. If you want to try another Cassandra Clare book I would recommend moving onto the dark artifices! Since you’ve read this one (and the rest a while back) you know the basics and you should be able to follow. In my opinion her writing and characters are so much better in that series!


    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for letting me know. I’m thinking I’ll at least read the next two books to get to know the characters but then I might take your advice and move on to another group of characters! I’m glad her writing and characters will improve, they’re the most common complaints I see in negative reviews.

      Thank you for your comment!💕

      Liked by 1 person

  2. This is really fun to read Ellyn 😂 I have a love-hate relationship with this series too, I love book 1, 2, and 5, but not the rest. I think their group dynamics definitely improved, buut Jace and Clary became really insufferable :’) I think I’m due for a reread, reading this makes me feel nostalgic!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m glad you enjoyed it, hopefully, I’ll have a review up for book 2 in a couple of weeks! 💕

      I’m glad the group dynamic improves because honestly I just want them all to get along! But damn, I already don’t like Jace (AT ALL) and I get the feeling it won’t take much for Clary to annoy me so I’m not super pumped for their inevitable long-suffering drama.

      I hope your re-read goes well! I plan on reading book 2 soon so hopefully, I enjoy it, like you did! ❤❤


    1. I’ve heard much better things about her newer books so I think I’ll at least read the first 3 books in the TMI series to get to know the characters again, and then hopefully I’ll move onto the TDA series!

      Thank you for your comment! 💕

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s